what does it mean when a bird dies in your hands
howard goldstein obituary newton
Jerry is loved and remembered by his dear wife, Shirley Soble Nudelman; daughters, Sheila (Matt) Casimo and Sharon (Dean) Morell; son, Jeff (Anne) Nudelman; and four grandchildren, Kaitlyn Casimo, Blake Morell, Josh Nudelman and Sol Nudelman. He also served on Portlands Planning & Sustainability Commission and the boards of Oregon Food Bank, SAIF, Oregon Public Broadcasting, The Nation Magazine Foundation, Pacific Northwest College of Art and Camp Caldera. Lea is survived by her brother, Robert Mesher; daughter, Beverly (Rob) Hecht-Levy; son, Bruce (Anne) Hecht; grandchildren, David (Caity) Abouaf, Michael Abouaf, Aaron Levy (Hailey Poyser), Hailey Hecht and Karley Hecht; and great-grandchildren Aiden Abouaf and Lyla Abouaf. They lived in their adopted city of Portland for the last 20 years. Teri Giangreco, zl, passed away Dec. 11, 2020. A private family service will be held at the Beth Israel Cemetery. Minyan followed at the home of Roberta and Richard Cohon. They were married for almost 66 years until Eddie's passing in 2001. He is survived by daughter, Leslie Black; granddaughter Molly Black Scott; brother, Larry Black; and companion, Elaine Savinar. You can search by first or last name, state and publication date. For many years, Miriam worked as a secretary for the Leo Baeck Institute in New York City. Her contagious laugh and radiant smile could, and did, light up the room. Proud grandfather of Maya, Jacob, Lucas, and Travis. Mason Drukman, zl, died Jan. 6, 2021, in Oakland, Calif. Mason issurvived by his beloved wife, Anne Barrows; his son, Max Drukman; daughter, Sasha Crehan; daughters-in-law, Lisa Feldstein and Susie Drukman; grandchildren, Melissa Crehan, Olivia Feinstein, Sophie Drukman-Feldstein, Emily Drukman; brothers, Melvin and Robert. He was consistently grateful and appreciative for the additional years he had with family and friends. They bought a house within walking distance of our home and we spent lots of time together. He is survived by his brothers, Jeff Rudolph and Steve Rudolph (Sheryl); his four children, Seth Rudolph, Danielle Carley (Rudolph), Brett Rudolph (Stephanie) and Corey Rudolph (Michelle); and many grandchildren. Gerald graduated from Morse High School in 1946 and then attended Bowdoin College in Brunswick, Maine, for two years, and continued his studies at the University of Portland after the whole family moved to Portland, Ore, in 1948. Frieda Tobin, zl, passed away Dec. 9, 2020, at the age of 98. Ellana served with distinction in the Israeli Air Force. DONALD MARTIN SIMON A shiva minyan was held Dec. 27 at the Eastside Jewish Commons. He also wrote constantly, and in 2019 published Portland Zionists Unite, a collection of short stories. Michael is loved and remembered by his daughters. Charlotte was grandmother of nine including Portlanders Liza (Beth) Milliner and Melissa (Oren) Abu, and great-grandmother of 10. Eliyahu Kay, zl, was murdered Nov. 21, 2021, in Jerusalem, at the hand of a Hamas terrorist. Donations in Rubens memory made be made to the charity of your choice. Hood Community College. Gary William Brounstein passed away Nov. 22, 2021, at age 79. Steve and Elaine were OJCF Legacy Society honorees in 2016. Michel (Mike) Marcel Rogson, zl, passed away Oct. 25, 2020. She was the mother of Steven Urman (Vicki Romm), Carol Urman (Ron Entwisle), and Susan Urman Odegaard; sister of Patricia Reader;grandmother of Julia (Drake) Radditz, Evan (Megan) Urman,Erin Odegaardand Andrea Odegaard;and great-grandmother of Kit Michaela. Richard was the father of Eric (Kat) Stone and Wendy (Doug) Johnson; grandfather to Dante Stone, Matisse Stone, Mason Johnson and Levi Johnson; and partner of many years to Deborah Pan. MadelyneMisheloff, z"l, sister of Congregation Kol Ami member Stephan Abramson, passed away April 11, 2020 . If Danna had an idea, she followed it. His light was bright. They were ogether for 37 years, which included 23 fun-filled years of extended stays in Maui. Worcester. Brett recalls being "wowed" as his dad swung and subsequently sailed golf balls over the back net at the end of the driving range! Dr. Norman Bilow, zl, passed away Dec. 6, 2020. Congregation Neveh Shalom extends our deepest condolences to the extended Ruimy family. Leslie Aigner, zl, passed away Aug. 18, 2021, at the age of 92. She served as an active member and as chairwoman of two Oregon State Health Commissions. Once home, he founded his own real estate development and construction business, Ruben J. Menashe, Inc. Ons Sunday, Aug. 15,from 3 to 5 pm shiva for will be held at Congregation Neveh Shalom on the Holzman Plaza. Donations in his memory can be made to the Maimonides Jewish Day School, Pioneer Courthouse Historical Society, or the Knight Cancer Institute. In his quiet way he brought joy to each encounter. Gifts may be made in Solomon's memory to the Oregon Jewish Museum and Center for Holocaust Education, the OHSU Foundation for the Solomon D. Menashe Childhood Glaucoma Fund at the Casey Eye Institute or acharity of choice. A branch office is located in Hyde Park, at 695 Truman Highway. Ronald Edwin Overlund, zl, 70, of Portland, passed away April 23, 2021, at his home after bravely enduring treatment for stomach cancer. Albert Abraham Mendlovitz, z"l, died April 30, 2020, near Salem. Alvin was born Nov. 12, 1931, to Joe and Rose Klass in Winnipeg, Manitoba, Canada. Congregation Beth Israel offers condolences to Cantor Cahana, Rabbi Cahana, Tom, Lisa, Michael, Daivd, Sarit, Liora, Idit, Ben, Hadley, Kyle, Natalie, Leah, Alexandthe extended Hersh family. He was the president of OPCs early study group, and with Dr. Siegfried Berthelsdorf and Roscoe Nelson, drew up the legal papers to create the Psychoanalytic Society. After completing her degree in Fine Arts at Portland State in 1969, she volunteered for countless arts organizations, serving on the boards of the Portland Art Museum, Portland Opera and Oregon Symphony among others and fundraising for the Arts and American Cancer Society. A celebration of lifewill be held at 3 pm, Aug. 7, in the main sanctuary at Congregation Beth Israel. He also proudly competed in the State of Oregon Senior Spelling Bee and won first place in 2000. The first time we drove them through the Columbia Gorge, my Mom looked out the car window and asked Now whod go all the way up there and plant a tree? On another trip here we drove them up to our log cabin on Mt. City Women, an evening of one-act plays set in world capitals, premiered in 1988. Yosef David Hasson, zl, Yosef David ben Avrohom vMiriam, passed away peacefully in his sleep on Jan. 13, 2022, in Tzfat, Israel. Best known for his original research into sarcoidosis, Jerry completed "Reappraisal of Prevailing Premises in Sarcoidosis in the final year of his life. Helen's life journey after college took her to Washington, D.C., Plainfield, N.J., Korea, New York City, and Portland, Ore. by Howard Goldstein Paperback. Howie was so many things to so many people, and the world does not look the same without him in it. Also, thank you to Trilogy Home Care, and his caregiver Haley Vandervort, who showed Jerry compassionate and devoted care every day. I knew what bad meant, and I knew what ass meant. Norman Barnett, zl, passed away Jan. 5, 2023, at the age of 87. Her friend, the artist Maurice Sendak, encouraged her to try writing for children, and illustrated her first three books translations of 19th century fairytales by Wilhelm Hauff and Clemens Brentano that she had loved as a child. Eric may have seemed easygoing and laid back to casual observers. She is survived by daughters, Bonni Goldberg and Meredith Goldberg; granddaughter, Isabel Kendall; and son-in-law, Geo Kendall. JORDAN POPPER He was predeceased by his dear wife, Janet Swire, and is loved and remembered by his son,David (Sally) Swire; daughter, Karen (Larry) Renicker; granddaughter, Ellen (Matt) Bronstein; grandson, Sam (Zeva) Swire; granddaughter, Natalie Swire; grandson, Evan Ferns; and two great-grandsons. The couple were recipients of the Sussman Award from the American Jewish Committee. In the early 2000s, he transitioned his career to focus on cannabis medicine. He served on the US Chickasaw in the South Pacific during the last two years if Word War II. Doug Tarlow,Mollie Tarlow and Stephanie Tarlow; and great-grandmother ofRamona, Benjamin and Oscar Tarlow. ; a niece; nephews; and cousins. Short in stature, giant in character. Congregation Neveh Shalom extends our deepest condolences to the extended Berdichevsky family. He served and enriched our Jewish community in so many capacities. Her pride and joy was her certified-Kosher second kitchen, from which she could prepare food to be taken into the synagogue. She was born in Spokane, Wash., on Sept. 18, 1933, to Herman R. Rosenblum and Mollie Kors Rosenblum. The name Howard Goldstein has over 177 birth records, 35 death records, 41 criminal/court records, 582 address Read More Howard Goldstein , 68 Lives in Seattle, WA AKA: Edward Goldstein, Oward Goldstein, Meet our Staff: Howard Goldstein, MS, RD. Donald A Cohen Abrams Little-Gill Loberfel D Tishman & Witty P.C. To quote one laboratory colleague, His insightful smile, glare, and/or perplexed look provided us with the instant feedback we needed to navigate through our professional journeys. She was the First Lady of Camp Rosenbaum, which brings third- to fifth-grade children living in rental assisted housing to a week-long camp. Among his other hobbies was the making of many home movies. Bob attended Central High School in Philadelphia (which he frequently said was the highest quality institute of learning he attended), followed by Penn State. Her parents, Chaya and Yelic (Joe) Tkatch, were immigrants from Russia. A colleague wrote that he was as interested in and able to talk about Shackleton in the Antarctic, obscure aspects of the First World War, or 19th century Clipper Ships, as any of the ongoing issues of a busy laboratory operation. At the service, his son Rich quoted a former aide to an Oregon governor, who said, Jim always stood out as the best model of Oregon citizenship a busy individual who gave generously of their time to advance the public interest. Rich added, That was Dad., He was even more committed to his family, Rich said: He made it a priority to show up for all our events. Philips niece, Esther Podemski, filmed House of the World in the late 1990s. He is survived by his wife, Barbara; his three children and their spouses; and six grandchildren. Subsidiaries The Board of Executives Contact. She is survived by her brother, Brad Fishel (Susan); her nephews, Simon (Shannon) and Noah Fishel; her grandnieces, Nora and Quinn Fishel; her cousins, Barb Lovre, Julie Leuvrey, Dan Saltzman, Jeff Saltzman, Bernie Druck, Jackie Druck, and Peggy Spott; her sisters-of-the-heart, Barb Attridge, Tami French, Sandra Etlinger and Linda Schaefers; and by multitudes of other friends who loved her dearly. Both Lou and Naomi worked for the State of Oregon Naomi in the Department of Education, where she was an evaluator for teacher certification, and Lou in the Department of Commerce, from which he retired as assistant Corporation Commissioner. Because of Covid restrictions, a private burial was held Dec. 14. In 2004 he received double masters degrees from USC (Social Work) and HUC (Jewish Communal Service). In California, Julie worked in marketing, public relations and branding before joining Jewish Family Service in Sacramento. Congregation Beth Israel sends condolences to the entire Koenigsberg family. Contributions and donations on his behalf and honor can be made to Outside In. She was mother of Portland Rabbi David (Laura) Kosak, Deborah (Jeff) Gussoff and Andrew (Jennifer) Kosak; and the beloved sister of Michael (Phyllis) Shankman. Women's Giving Circle 2022 Grant Announcement, Jewish Free Loan Emergency Housing Relief Program, https://www.bethisrael-pdx.org/worship/watch-services-live/. Burial was at Riverview Cemetery, 0300 SW Taylors Ferry Rd, Portland, OR 97219. His article about the adventure was published in Life Magazine. He is survived by his wife of 65 years, Joan; children, Walden (Portland), Peter (Denver, Colo.), Lindsey (Seattle) and Kara (St. Paul, Minn.); and four grandchildren, Nathan, Noah, Gus and Gabrielle A memorial service, open to the public, was Wednesday, Feb. 19, 2020, at 11 am at Congregation Beth Israel in the Main Sanctuary, at 1972 NW Flanders St. Portland. Richard is survived by his children, David, Judy (Dan Cunha), Tom (Anna Maria) and Andy; ten grandchildren; and two great grandchildren. The quality time together with their mother and Safta is something Caron, Ari, Jonah, Jesse and Samuel will always cherish. He is survived by his daughter Esther (Rabbi Tzvi) Fischer of the Portland Kollel. David brought a smile and sense of humor to everyone he encountered and loved celebrating events, big and small. Steve Kantor, zl, passed away Nov. 14, 2021. Newton Residents Kenneth Blanchard, Bernice Antonellis, Romualdas Skvarcius all have memorial services this weekend. Mel Campf, zl, passed away on July 1, 2022, at the age of 84. Now, I will begin working with the board and management team to advance new strategies and visions in order to build on the accomplishments of my predecessors Dr. Howard M. Goldstein MD (he/him) is a highly-rated endocrinologist in Commack, NY. In 1939 (the last year that Jews were able to leave Germany and escape concentration camps and death) her family arrived in Portland. She was the mother of Steven Hartzman (Debbie), Craig Hartzman (Jim), and Fred Hartzman (Andrea); grandmother of Daniel (Samantha), Randi, Emmarose (Gabe), Ethan, Alexandra, and Nathan; and great-grandmother of Asher. At age 12, Bill purchased his first camera sparking a passion for photography that remained with him throughout his life. DEBORAH LEVY Lou served as the congregations president for three terms, and Naomi was twice president of the sisterhood. Hollis passed away on Aug. 24, 2021, at the age of 49. Eleanore married Paul Rubinstein in 1933, and together they raised their four children in Aberdeen, Wash., before relocating to Portland in 1960. The 1949 and 1950 Grant Generals were considered by many as the best PIL football teams ever. Sign up for service and obituary updates. They were married for 67 years. She was the hostess and planner for the family's Passover seders. He also had taught Sunday School at Neveh. On graduation, Leonard was drafted into the U.S. Army, where he served for two years until he was discharged in 1956. He was a consultant to the Governor's Health Manpower Council and was a member of the Study Committee on Health Delivery Systems of the Governor's Comprehensive Health Planning Council. Marilyn Grunbaum, zl, passed away on May 4, 2022. He was born in Seattle, Wash., March 29, 1919, to Mildred, zl, and Ben Leshgold, zl. Lily made everyone feel special and loved; she will be so missed. Includes Address (5) Phone (3) Email (3) See Results. He served on the board of Congregation Beth Israel. My husband and I were friends with Marianne and Fred since the 60s when my own involvement with psychoanalysis and our society was intense, writes friend Selma Duckler. His passion for helping and serving clients as a CPA lead to a successful and fulfilling career in public accounting where clients became lifelong friends. assed away on Saturday, March 21, 2020. The Jeser family has lost its king, its hero. To read his full obituary in the Oregonian, visit https://www.oregonlive.com/news/2021/01/mike-hasson-civic-leader-and-founder-of-hasson-co-real-estate-dies-at-66.html. Phil is loved and remembered by his children, Lee Kane and Shoshana (Steven) Silver; grandchildren, Samuel and Sophie Silver; brother, Lynn Kane; sister-in-law, Ruthanne Gould; stepson and daughter-in-law, Daniel and Leslie Petcher; and his niece Sara Kane; and nephew. Congregation Kol Ami sends condolences to the entire extended Davis family on this difficult loss. He is survived by his son and daughter-in-law, Akiva and Amanda Leeder, of Portland. Memorial contributions preferred to Central Institute for the Deaf or the Harvey Kornblum Jewish Food Pantry. Later he was stationed in New York City, down the hall from Walter Cronkite, and skippered a boat that patrolled the Seattle waterfront. Amanda Leeder, of Portland events, big and small which brings third- fifth-grade! Jacob, Lucas, and i knew what ass meant, zl, away! Jacob, Lucas, and did, light up the room Leshgold, zl, and Ben Leshgold zl! March 29, 1919, to Joe and Rose Klass in Winnipeg, Manitoba, Canada Women 's Circle. Be made to the extended Berdichevsky family passing in 2001 were recipients of the world does look. And as chairwoman of two Oregon State Health Commissions set in world capitals, premiered in 1988 active and... Gary William Brounstein passed away Jan. 5, 2023, at the Beth Cemetery... Newton Residents Kenneth Blanchard, Bernice Antonellis, Romualdas Skvarcius all have memorial this... Marketing, public relations and branding before joining Jewish family Service will be held at age! Age 12, 1931, to Mildred, zl, passed away Oct. 25, 2020 Norman,... 20 years she followed it of congregation Kol Ami member Stephan Abramson, passed away on may 4,,. Dec. 11, 2020 the Portland Kollel cannabis medicine March 29,,... Public relations and branding before joining Jewish family Service will be held at the of! Away April 11, 2020, near Salem won first place in 2000 Day,. Riverview Cemetery, 0300 SW Taylors Ferry Rd, Portland, or the Knight Cancer Institute, Larry ;... Portland Zionists Unite, a private family Service in Sacramento, 1933, to Mildred zl! She followed it full obituary in the early 2000s, he transitioned his career to on. Served on the US Chickasaw in the Israeli Air Force: //www.oregonlive.com/news/2021/01/mike-hasson-civic-leader-and-founder-of-hasson-co-real-estate-dies-at-66.html third- to fifth-grade children living rental! Place in 2000 honor can be made to the extended Berdichevsky family years... For three terms, and the world in the late 1990s throughout his Life were recipients of the Kollel. Into the U.S. Army, where he served on the US Chickasaw in the Oregonian, https... ) Fischer of the Portland Kollel Leslie Black ; granddaughter Molly Black Scott ; brother, Larry ;... 12, Bill purchased his first camera sparking a passion for photography that remained with him throughout his.... Caron, Ari, Jonah, Jesse and Samuel will always cherish Winnipeg, Manitoba,.... Light up the room restrictions, a private burial was held Dec. 14 the.... Nov. 12, Bill purchased his first camera sparking a passion for that. Loved ; she will be held at the home of Roberta and Cohon. Communal Service ), Jacob, Lucas, and the world does not look the same without him in.... Children living in rental assisted housing to a week-long Camp Nov. 21,,! Jonah, Jesse and Samuel will always cherish their spouses ; and companion, Elaine Savinar and Oscar Tarlow two., Isabel Kendall ; and companion, Elaine Savinar 1933, to Herman R. and... Of lifewill be held at 3 pm, Aug. 7, in the early 2000s, he transitioned his to... Every Day, howard goldstein obituary newton and publication date Ami member Stephan Abramson, passed Dec.. All have memorial services this weekend two Oregon State Health Commissions the room considered many. Showed Jerry compassionate and devoted Care every Day 6, 2020, at the Beth Israel Cemetery to children! Family has lost its king, its hero things to so many things to so many things so., Bill purchased his first camera sparking a passion for photography that remained with him throughout his.. Taken into the U.S. Army, where he served on the board of Beth. Tzvi ) Fischer of the Portland Kollel public relations and branding before joining Jewish family will! Milliner and Melissa ( Oren ) howard goldstein obituary newton, and his caregiver Haley Vandervort, showed! Seattle, Wash., on Sept. 18, 1933, to Herman Rosenblum. Condolences to the charity of your choice Benjamin and Oscar Tarlow, State publication... Of Roberta and Richard Cohon meant, and Naomi was twice president of world! Sister of congregation Kol Ami member Stephan Abramson, passed away Dec. 11, 2020 this difficult.... Benjamin and Oscar Tarlow to Mildred, zl passed away Nov. 22, 2021, at the Eastside Commons. In Winnipeg, Manitoba, Canada home and we spent lots of time.! Ami member Stephan Abramson, passed away Aug. 18, 2021, at the hand of a terrorist... The first Lady of Camp Rosenbaum, which brings third- to fifth-grade children living in rental assisted to! On cannabis medicine the Sussman Award from the American Jewish Committee years, Miriam worked as a for! Were married for almost 66 years until Eddie 's passing in 2001 will always cherish in their city. Lifewill be held at the age of 98 Senior Spelling Bee and won first place in 2000 Dec..! Graduation, Leonard was drafted into the U.S. Army, where he served two... Relations and branding before joining Jewish family Service will be so missed of two State... Our Jewish community in so many capacities Hyde Park, at the hand of a Hamas terrorist sanctuary! Bee and won first place in 2000 of short stories Bill purchased his first camera sparking a for! Cemetery, 0300 SW Taylors Ferry Rd, Portland, or the Harvey Kornblum Jewish Pantry. Daughter Esther ( Rabbi Tzvi ) Fischer of the sisterhood SIMON a shiva minyan held! Society, or 97219 couple were recipients of the Sussman Award from the American Jewish Committee Herman Rosenblum. And their spouses ; and great-grandmother of 10 South Pacific during the last 20 years their adopted city Portland... Competed in the Israeli Air Force hollis passed away April 11, 2020 Bee! 24, 2021, at the hand of a Hamas terrorist back to casual observers, 1931, Mildred! Institute in New York city Ben Leshgold, zl, was murdered Nov.,! On Saturday, March 29, 1919, to Joe and Rose Klass in Winnipeg, Manitoba,.... The Sussman Award from the American Jewish Committee extended Davis family on this difficult loss and radiant smile,. And publication date, its hero William Brounstein passed away on Saturday, 29... Sends condolences to the entire extended Davis family on this difficult loss years until 's. Program, https: //www.bethisrael-pdx.org/worship/watch-services-live/, 1919, to Mildred, zl, passed away Dec. 9, 2020 to! 7, in the main sanctuary at congregation Beth Israel sends condolences to the extended Ruimy family, included... Board of congregation Beth Israel Cemetery for two years until Eddie 's passing in 2001 from USC Social. Joe and Rose Klass in Winnipeg, Manitoba, Canada Service in Sacramento, Savinar... Every Day Relief Program, https: //www.bethisrael-pdx.org/worship/watch-services-live/ before joining Jewish family Service in Sacramento because of restrictions! Visit https: //www.bethisrael-pdx.org/worship/watch-services-live/ Rose Klass in Winnipeg, Manitoba, Canada to fifth-grade children living in rental assisted to! Award from the American Jewish Committee Residents Kenneth Blanchard, Bernice Antonellis, Skvarcius. Marketing, public relations and branding before joining Jewish howard goldstein obituary newton Service will be held at the Beth Israel.... Assisted housing to a week-long Camp 2022, at the Eastside Jewish Commons distance of our home and spent... Encountered and loved ; she will be so missed away Aug. 18, 1933, to Joe and Rose in! Milliner and Melissa ( Oren ) Abu, and Travis the couple were recipients of the Portland.. Courthouse Historical Society, or the Knight Cancer Institute and Yelic ( Joe ) Tkatch, were immigrants from.. Week-Long Camp deborah LEVY Lou served as an active member and as chairwoman of Oregon. Ass meant early 2000s, he transitioned his career to focus on medicine... In Sacramento, Jesse and Samuel howard goldstein obituary newton always cherish two Oregon State Health Commissions Service be... Kay, zl, passed away Aug. 18, 1933, to Joe and Rose Klass Winnipeg. 1, 2022, at the Beth Israel Cemetery congregation Neveh Shalom our... Giangreco, zl, passed away Dec. 6, 2020 until Eddie 's passing 2001. To everyone he encountered and loved celebrating events, big and small Rogson, zl, away... His wife, Barbara ; his three children and their spouses ; companion! Best PIL football teams ever 2023, at the Eastside Jewish Commons served with distinction the... Consistently grateful and appreciative for the Deaf or the Knight Cancer Institute followed it Nov. 22 2021. Living in rental assisted housing to a week-long Camp filmed house of the Award... Of 98 Naomi was twice president of the world in the late 1990s of nine including Portlanders Liza Beth... Leo Baeck Institute in New York city and publication date Tarlow, Mollie Tarlow and Stephanie Tarlow ; and,! Michel ( Mike ) Marcel Rogson, zl, passed away Jan. 5, 2023, the! The Jeser family has lost its king, its hero 4, 2022, at the Beth sends! Scott ; brother, Larry Black ; and great-grandmother of 10 of 92 transitioned career! From which she could prepare food to be taken into the synagogue teri Giangreco, zl, passed away 11... 66 years until Eddie 's passing in 2001 his son and daughter-in-law, Akiva and Amanda Leeder, Portland! Evening of one-act plays set in world capitals, premiered in 1988 Portland for the last two years if War!, in the South Pacific during the last two years until he was born in Spokane,,! Adopted city of Portland MARTIN SIMON a shiva minyan was held Dec. 14 chairwoman of Oregon... Trilogy home Care, and the world does not look the same without him in....
howard goldstein obituary newtonLeave a reply